non-indexed copy platform for me!

Saturday, August 22, 2009

Vimeo Youtube comparison

The smackdown between Vimeo and Youtube (both free online video portals) has a clear winner- in some respects.

It really depends on what you want most. If you're looking for the best quality output for your video, Vimeo wins hands down every time. I've included the two versions below, both from the same source file. There is a definite difference. Youtube shows more artifacts in the video (artifacts are the jaggy lines or areas that appear in most internet video. Vimeo is extremely clean. This is for non-HD. If you click HD on youtube, the video will increase in size but the artifacts are still there.

Regarding Youtube, there are some distinct perks not on Vimeo, primarily the ability to annotate your video on the fly. You can add annotations and links anywhere in the video once it is posted. That's powerful stuff and may be worth the slight hit on video quality. There are things you can do in your source file to improve quality but I won't delve into that topic now.

Vimeo will remove your video if it's a blatant commercial. They're fairly lenient but if you turn your commentary into a listing rather than just embedding the video in your own site and adding your own commentary, the staff will probably remove your video (they'll let you know in a polite email). If it has at least some artistic value, it's more likely to stay. The site's TOS states no commercials including real estate walkthroughs. That's probably enough to throw up a red flag for most real estate applications.

If you want to post your custom videos, you're taking your chances with Vimeo.

A final note, I have the fastest connection around for miles, 20/5 MB, that's faster than 3 T1s but Youtube still stalls on some videos. I suppose it's just a matter of which server your video is on and how busy it is.







Dave Keys - Orange County Web Design

No comments:

Post a Comment

Followers